Disarming the Impulsive and Suicidal

Over the 2014/15 holiday season, a mass-murder in Edmonton and a gang-related shooting at an Ottawa shopping outlet once again dominated headlines. Shortly thereafter, the Charlie Hebdo incident occurred in France. These are the stories that we most often read about, and often drive the gun-control discussion.

But with most of the attention given to mass shootings and street crimes in the debate over public safety, it is easy to overlook the incidence of gun-related suicides. In reality, suicides account for over 70% of gun-related deaths in Canada.

It is true that guns are not the only means of committing suicide, nor are they the most common method in most countries. The World Health Organization (WHO) released its first ever report on suicides in 2014, in which it stated that hanging accounts for 50% of suicides in high-income countries, compared to 18% of cases involving firearms.

However, when focusing on the Americas alone, firearms account for 46% of suicides.

The report identifies a number of relevant interventions for health system and societal risk factors, including the restriction of access to means of suicide. There is a correlation between proportions of households owning firearms and proportions of gun-related suicide. Furthermore, restrictions on gun ownership in several countries have led to a reduction in gun-related suicides in those countries.

Firearms provide a reliable, quick and painless means of committing suicide for impulsive individuals with little chance of recovery and re-evaluation. Dr. Alan Drummond of the Canadian Association for Emergency Physicians had this to say in his support of keeping the long-gun registry:

“Suicide, contrary to public opinion, is often an impulsive gesture. Keeping guns away from depressed people is essential. In the assaults and murders I have seen that have involved guns, the perpetrators acted on impulse and the unsafely stored long gun was readily available.”

Unsuccessful suicide attempts using firearms, while rare, often leaves the individual with serious and irrecoverable injuries such as permanent brain injury, blindness and paralysis.

Common-sense arguments aside, the empirical evidence suggests that gun laws work in reducing the number of suicides. The Institut national de santé publique du Québec submitted that since the Firearms Act came into force, the number of suicides in Canada has dropped by an average of 250 per year. Michael Bryant, a former attorney-general of Ontario, has also made it known that he believes a gun registry lowers the rate of suicide in Canada:

“Suicides dropped dramatically in Canada thanks to the federal gun registry. Not only do statistics prove as much, it stands to reason that with improved gun safety comes decreased gun fatalities; with fewer tools-of-choice for suicides available, fewer suicides occur.”

Mr. Bryant also raised a legal issue in response to the then-proposed abolition of the long-gun registry: would the courts uphold a law that eliminates proven safety measures?

The relationship between gun laws and suicide is apparent, and should not be overlooked in the debate for tougher gun restrictions.



1 thought on “Disarming the Impulsive and Suicidal

  1. I respect your opinion on the need for gun regulations in Canada, but please don’t equate the registration of firearms and anything but useless. Correlation does not imply causation. As you stated, suicide is for the most part impulsive, and registering a firearm has ZERO influence on that aspect of suicide decision making. The part of the firearms act which requires safe storage of a firearm when not in use or being maintained is the part of the act which assists in the declining numbers of firearm suicide victims. Not registering a firearm. Otherwise a similar train of thought would be that registering cars will reduce the number of vehicle accidents that occur.

    Research shows that mental illness is the most important risk factor for suicide; and that more than 90% of people who commit suicide have a mental or addictive disorder. That is a direct quote from Statistics Canada. I will also agree that the RATES of suicide have fallen, the actual numbers of suicides from 2000 to 2011 has never dropped below 2000 levels.

    Statistics Canada shows that during the same period, 2000-2011 the following was also true. Suicide by hanging increased as suicide by firearms decrease. So by your same logic of causation, I can infer that those individuals just chose a different means to commit suicide.

    Mental Health is the driving cause of the majority of violence than befalls us all. Please do not put a dislike or fear of firearms as the cause of the world’s ills, because you are then purposely clouding the issue with unproven validations. As stated before Correlation does not imply causation.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s